Tefillah 058

of the Rabbinical Assembly in Israel
HALAKHAH STUDY GROUP
THE HALAKHAH OF TEFILLAH
It is a mitzvah to recite the Amidah every day, for it says [Exodus 23:25], "To worship the Lord your God", and the oral tradition teaches that this 'worship' is the Amidah, for it says [Deuteronomy 11:13] "To worship him with all your heart" and the sages said "which worship is in the heart? – it is prayer [the Amidah]" [Rambam, Mishneh Torah, Tefillah 1:1].
EXPLANATIONS (continued):
62:
Our study of the benedictions of the Amidah now brings us to the third of the seven benedictions. This berakhah is termed by the sages and by tradition Kedushat ha-Shem [God's Sanctity] – often abbreviated simply to Kedushah [Sanctity].
63:
The topic of this benediction is as simple as the previous topic was convoluted: Our God, the Deity of the Founding Parents [first benediction], the Deity who liberates the oppressed and controls the keys of life and death [second benediction] – our God is holy. In the text of the Amidah that is currently accepted this concept is illustrated by allusion to the angelic chorus envisioned by the prophets [Isaiah 6:3 and Ezekiel 3:12]. The short text reads as follows:
You are holy, Your name is holy, and holy beings daily praise You. Praised be God, the Holy Deity.
Not only is the Deity holy per se but even the terms that we use to identify the Deity are holy. Our sages determined that seven appellations applicable to God are sacred, must not be misused, must not be desecrated, must not be erased. Rambam [Hilkhot Yesodei ha-Torah 6:2] lists them as follows:
The seven names are:
- The Tetragrammaton, written Yod Hé Vav Hé; this is the Ineffable Name which is [by tradition] written [and pronounced] Adonai
- El
- Elo'ah
- Elohim [and its suffixes]
- Elohei [and Elohai]
- Shaddai
- Tzeva'ot
64:
The "holy beings" referred to in the benediction are the angelic beings envisaged by the prophets as surrounding the celestial throne and sanctifying God in eternal song. Isaiah calls them Seraphs; Ezekiel calls them Ĥayyot and Ofanim. By custom, when the Cantor repeats the Amidah out loud this reference to the angelic chorus is greatly amplified, but we shall study this amplification as part of our study of the Repetition of the Amidah in general, after we conclude our present survey of the [private] Amidah.
65:
The ancient ritual of Eretz-Israel tried hard to avoid reference to this angelic chorus. The daily text made no reference to it and the cantor's amplification was (eventually) permitted only on Shabbat and Festivals. This is the text of the third benediction as was customary in Eretz-Israel:
Holy are You and awsome is Your Name; there is no deity but You, as it is written [Isaiah 5:16]: "The God of Hosts is exalted in judgment and the holy Deity is sanctified in justice." Praised be God, the holy Deity.
If one peruses the Hebrew text of this version it will be noticed that in our present tradition this wording replaces the usual wording (in #63 above) during the ten penitential days from Rosh ha-Shanah until Yom Kippur. The only difference is that in Eretz-Israel they did not change the wording of the concluding berakhah: "The holy Deity" was not replaced by "the holy Sovereign" as is our present custom during these days.
66:
Since we have mentioned the High Holydays and since Rosh ha-Shanah is almost upon us let us deviate for a short while from the Shabbat Amidah and note that on Rosh ha-Shanah and on Yom Kippur it is customary to greatly expand this third benediction – both in the private Amidah and in the cantor's repetition. Here is a modern translation of Kedushat ha-Shem as it is said on these three days:
You are holy, Your name is holy, and holy beings daily praise You. So, set Your awe over all creation. Let all be united together to do Your will whole-heartedly. We know that Yours is the dominion, the power, and the might, and that Your name is awesome over all that You created. Grant honour, hope and confidence to the people of Israel that seek and yearn for You, happiness in the land of Israel, joy in the city of Jerusalem, and burgeoning fortune to Your Davidic servant; in our times a steady flame for the Messianic line. The upright will rejoice, injustice will be annulled, and all evil will disappear as in a puff of smoke – when You finally remove all tyranny from our world. Then You alone will rule over all Your works, on Mount Zion, in Jerusalem the holy City, as is written in Your holy scripture [Psalm 146:10]: "God shall reign forever, your God, O Zion, for all generations. Hallelujah." Holy are You and awsome is Your Name; there is no deity but You, as it is written [Isaiah 5:16]: "The God of Hosts is exalted in judgment and the holy Deity is sanctified in justice." Praised be God, the holy sovereign.
I offer no Hebrew text for this quotation as it is readily accessible in all festival prayer books.
67:
When we come to investigate the origin of this passage we discover something very interesting. In order to understand this discovery we must preface a short passage from the Mishnah [Rosh ha-Shanah 4:5]
You can find a full explanation of this mishnah in Tractate Rosh ha-Shanah. Here a very brief explanation must suffice.
The Musaf Amidah of Rosh ha-Shanah is different from all other texts of the Amidah in that it has extra benedictions which house three passages unique to the day. These passages are called Malkhuyot, Zikhronot and Shofarot. In the mishnah there is a disagreement between Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi Yoĥanan ben-Nuri concerning the way in which these passages are to be integrated into the Amidah. (The way we do it today is according to the opinion of Rabbi Akiva.) Rabbi Akiva is of the opinion that Malkhuyot is to be integrated into the fourth benediction of the Amidah and that then two further benedictions are to be added for the other two passages. Rabbi Yoĥanan ben-Nuri holds that Malkhuyot is to be integrated into the third benediction, Kedushat ha-Shem, not the fourth. Most scholars are agreed that the expanded version of the third benediction that we use on Rosh ha-Shanah and Yom Kippur is, in fact, the text for Malkhuyot according to Rabbi Yoĥanan ben-Nuri. In compensation for the fect that it was not used during Musaf on Rosh-ha-Shanah it was included in all the Amidot on these three holiest days of the year.
68:
Those who are interested in seeing the third benediction of the Amidah as it is reflected in my modern shiv'ata can find it here. In English it reads as follows:
Daily anew they that dwell in His minor temple sanctify our Holy One,
High and exalted, great and tremendous, in sanctity enthroned upon Israel's praises.
Praised be God, the holy Deity.
This concludes our study of the third benediction of the Amidah.

Donation Form