Sotah 048
|
BET MIDRASH VIRTUALI
of the Rabbinical Assembly in Israel
RABIN MISHNAH STUDY GROUP
|
|
|
A fiancée and an woman waiting for levirate marriage do not drink and do not collect their Ketubah, for it is said, "when a wife, being under her husband, goes astray": this excludes a fiancée and an woman waiting for levirate marriage. A widow married to a High Priest, a divorcee or Ĥalutzah married to an ordinary priest, an illegitimate Israelite woman married to an Israelite, and an Israelite woman married to an illegitimate man – none of these drink nor do they collect their Ketubah.
EXPLANATIONS (continued):
2:
The term fiancée as used in our mishnah denotes a woman who has accepted Kiddushin from a man but has not yet completed the marriage process. To all intents and purposes this halakhic status no longer exists. For full details concerning the status of the fiancée, or betrothed woman, one must refer to the copious material on this subject that our study of Tractate Kiddushin produced. For our present purposes let us just review the main points. 3: 4: 5: To be continued. DISCUSSION:
We are very behind with some of the discussion items, and I shall try to catch up over the next few days. Quite some time ago I wrote: The Torah [Leviticus 21:1-2] prohibits 'the sons of Aaron' from coming into contact with a corpse with the exception of that of a close family member: parent, sibling or spouse. Lee Irwin writes:
Are children not included in "close family member"? I thought three generations were included (parents, siblings, children) and spouse. I respond: Lee is absolutely correct. The Torah requires statutory mourning for parents, siblings and offspring; it was the sages who added the spouse. I wrote: A Jewish manservant must not wash the feet of his master, nor put his shoes on him, nor carry his things before him when going to the bath-house. Art Kamlet asks: How do we understand this when considering the obligations of the Levite towards the Kohen? I respond: I do not understand the question. Are we to consider the relationship between a Kohen and a Levi as being one of master and slave?! This is obviously not the case, therefore surely the observation is irrelevant. Concerning slavery in general, Albert Ringer writes: I am sorry to say, I find it a bit too much oversimplification to speak about "what the world generally calls 'a slave'". Our modern view of servitude is colored very much by the suffering the West brought over people of African origin. In the Greek and Roman world, a large spectrum of different approaches to servitude existed. On one side of the scale, you could find slaves that were sent by the Roman court to the mines or gallows. These people did not survive their lot long. On the other side you could find a privileged slave, the pedagogue for instance, who in the classical Greek world had more status than women had. In the Hellenistic and Roman world in general, citizens had a higher status than native people of the land, who where considered captives of war and had to pay tribute. Jews that lived in cities probably were considered free people in Hellenistic times, native people by Rome. There is a theory that this loss of status is the main reason behind the Jewish revolt in Alexandria. In Egypt in ancient times, all the land and all the people belonged to Pharaoh and technically where slaves. Torah knows about this and tells us that Joseph brought this about by forcing the people to sell themselves to Pharaoh in the seven meager years. Pharaoh is asked to let our people go, in a sense to serve the Eternal one instead. I suppose that is the basis under the Jewish way to look at slavery. A Jewish slave should be free enough to personally hold mitzvoth. I respond: My original comment was directed to the understanding of slavery in the Western world. |
Click here to access the BMV Home Page, which includes the RMSG archive.
To subscribe to the Rabin Mishnah Study Group email service
click here.
To unsubscribe send an email to nhis address
For information on how to support the Virtual Bet Midrash by making a donation or dedicating a shiur please click here.
Please use nhis address for discussion, queries, comments and requests.