Avot262

of the Rabbinical Assembly in Israel
RABIN MISHNAH STUDY GROUP
TRACTATE AVOT, CHAPTER FOUR, MISHNAH TWENTY-TWO (recap):
Rabbi Shim'on ben-El'azar says: Do not [try to] placate someone when he is [still] angry; do not offer comfort when his dead is lying before him [unburied]; do not question him when he is making a vow; and do not make efforts to see him when he is in disgrace.
EXPLANATIONS (continued):
5:
The teaching offered by Rabbi Shim'on ben-El'azar in our present mishnah is fourfold, and each of the items is a piece of homely human wisdom.
6:
Do not placate someone when he is angry. On the one hand anger is a very human reaction; on the other hand it is deprecated by the sages. The kind of anger that the sages deprecate is when the anger burns so strong that a person loses all self-control. In his halakhic compendium Mishneh Torah [De'ot 2:3] Rambam teaches that one should train oneself in all human chacteristics and behaviour patterns to opt for the Golden Mean. However, he says, that there are certain characteristics that must be shunned in extreme – and one of them is anger:
Anger is a very bad characteristic and a person should avoid it in the extreme opposite degree. One should teach oneself not to be angry even about something which is worthy of anger… The early sages said that when one loses one's temper it is as if he were worshipping an idol. They also said that when a sage loses his temper he loses his wisdom… and that the life of people prone to anger is just not worth living. That is why they gave instruction to keep far from anger…
Clearly, the anger referred to here is an anger that is so great that for the moment it consumes every other aspect of a person's personality: they truly are out of control because their anger has taken complete control. They are worshipping the vilest of all idols: they are worshipping themselves. Rabbi Shim'on ben-El'azar says that in such circumstances there is no point in trying to placate the irate or to reason with them. There must come a time when the anger burns itself out. Only then will that person be able to listen to reason and reasons.
7:
Do not offer comfort when his dead is lying before him. We have spoken before of the burial customs in the time of the sages. When we studied Berakhot 3:1, for example, I wrote:
In Mishnaic times burial plots were situated outside the towns and villages, mostly on the eastern side of town and some way off. The reason for this was the manner of burial. The body of the deceased was laid on ledges or "shelves" hewn into the rocky walls of a handy cave, whose entrance was then carefully blocked until it was next needed to be opened. About a year later the family would enter the cave and retrieve the bones of the deceased, put them in a small receptacle and bury them. The prevailing winds in Eretz-Israel are westerly; thus on most days of the year the unpleasant smell coming from the burial place would be wafted away from the settlement [Bava Batra 2:9]. (On those few days when the hot easterlies blow in from the desert (Ĥamsin, Sharav) the stench must have been unbearable!
It should now be clear why condolences were not to be offered until after the burial: the bereaved was to be occupied solely with the arrangements for the disposal of his dead.
To be continued.
DISCUSSION:
In Avot 258 I brought the story of how Rav Kahana bolted to Eretz-Israel and had been forewarned by his teacher not to enter into halakhic debate with Rabbi Yoĥanan. Amnon Ron'el says that this advice turned out to be "advice of Aĥitophel" [see the story in 2 Samuel 15] "because Rav Kahana had now to make do with a weak study companion."
I respond:
Woe to the ear that hears this, woe to the eye that reads! The study companion to whom Amnon refers was Resh Lakish, one of the very great Amora'im of Eretz-Israel. You can read about him in Sanhedrin 021, #8.
Donation Form