Avot177
|
BET MIDRASH VIRTUALI
of the Rabbinical Assembly in Israel
RABIN MISHNAH STUDY GROUP
|
|
|
TRACTATE AVOT, CHAPTER THREE, MISHNAH ELEVEN):
Rabbi Dosa ben-Hyrkanos says: Sleeping in the morning, [drinking] wine at noon, children's chatter, and attendance at the synagogues of ignoramuses will take a person out of this world.
EXPLANATIONS:
1:
In some codices this mishnah is presented as a continuation of the previous mishnah. Almost nothing is known about Rabbi Dosa ben-Hyrkanos. He belongs to the generation of Yavneh – a contemporary of Rabbis Eli'ezer and Yehoshu'a and Rabban Gamli'el. Apart from our prsent mishnah he is quoted seven more times in the Mishnah, and in all cases his opinion is rejected by the majority. Most famously, one year he was involved in the controversy between Rabban Gamli'el and Rabbi Yehoshu'a concerning the date of Rosh ha-Shanah [Rosh ha-Shanah 2:8] 2: 3: 4: To be continued. DISCUSSION:
In Avot 173 we learned that Rabbi Chanina ben-Dosa and his wife were loath to accept charity – even if it meant foregoing a suitable Shabbat meal and this is presented as laudable.
Ze'ev Orzech writes: What if instead of charity we speak of tzedakah? Are they not depriving someone of the opportunity to perform a mitzvah? I respond: I really do not understand the logic of Ze'ev's question here. Are we to do things simply so that someone else may perform a mitzvah at our expense, as it were? Should I starve myself so that another may perform the mitzvah of feeding me? Should I go naked so that another may perform the mitzvah of clothing me? If I am in dire need it is everyone's duty to help me; if I do not think that my situation is dire, that I can manage with what I have, I should not ask for or accept charity. All this is from the point of view of the person who is poverty-stricken. However, from the point of view of anyone else who knows of such a person's situation, in his monumental halakhic compendium Mishneh Torah [Matnot Aniyyim 7:9], Rambam states:
If a poor person does not want to receive charity [others] should shower him [with necessities] and give them to him as a gift or a loan.
The greatest goal of the would-be sage is to study more and more Torah. However, as we have seen previously on several occasions, elsewhere in Mishneh Torah [Talmud Torah 3:10], Rambam states:
Anyone who decides to study Torah [exclusively] – not to engage in a trade but to live off charity – is desecrating God's name, bringing the Torah into disrepute, quenching the brightness of the faith, doing himself a disservice and denying himself the life to come… Any Torah[-study] which is not accompanied by earning a living in the end will be void and simply encourage sin. Ultimately such a person will be robbing the public.
|